> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://ericavincellimortgage.contentflow.media/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Diversified on Paper: 3 Ways to Spot Index Concentration in Canadian Portfolios
- URL: https://ericavincellimortgage.contentflow.media/diversified-on-paper-3-ways-to-spot-index-concentration-in-canadian-portfolios/
- Published: 2026-10-10T13:09:33.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-10T13:09:33.000Z
- Author: Erica Vincelli
- Tags: #auto-publish

Most Canadians who say they're well diversified are counting funds, not checking what's inside them. Surveys of Canadian investors keep finding the same gap: high confidence in diversification, and very little attention to index concentration. Here's how to check your own portfolio this week, using documents you already have.

1. **Pull the fact sheet for every ETF or index fund you own and write down two numbers: top-ten holdings weight and largest sector weight.** Your provider's website lists both. Then do the blended math. Take a common Ottawa setup: half in an S&P 500 ETF, half in a TSX Composite ETF. The S&P 500's top ten holdings now make up roughly 38% to 39% of the index, and Financials carried roughly 36% to 37% of the TSX. On a 50/50 split, that works out to:

> about 15% to 17% of your money in ten U.S. companies, plus about 15% in Canadian financials

Before any other overlap, that's roughly a third of your portfolio in two narrow groups: large U.S. tech and Canadian banks and insurers. "I feel like I should be diversified, I own two ETFs" is a fair thing to think. The fact sheets usually show otherwise.

1. **List your net worth in three columns: home equity, investments and income source. Mark anything tied to Canadian housing or Canadian banks.** This is where concentration gets personal. If you own a home or rentals in Ontario, hold a TSX index fund and work in a field linked to the domestic economy, a lot of your wealth depends on one country's credit cycle. Bank earnings and housing activity tend to move together. National home sales slipped 0.7% month over month in August 2026\. That figure isn't alarming on its own, but it shows how easily your house and your bank-heavy fund can respond to the same pressure. The same applies to trade. In August 2026, the U.S. imposed a 50% tariff on certain Canadian imports, a shock that reaches the broader Canadian economy, not one company. Landlords face this most directly. If you hold rental property and a TSX fund, you own Canadian real estate twice, and you may also hold the lenders that finance it.
2. **Open your account statements and note which holdings sit in RRSP, TFSA and non-registered accounts, then check what your investment borrowing actually buys.** Concentration is also a question of structure. U.S. dividends paid through Canadian-listed ETFs face a 15% withholding tax, and where you hold those funds affects how much of that you get back. If you run the Smith Manoeuvre™ or cash damming on a rental, the CRA generally allows you to deduct interest on money borrowed to earn income in a non-registered account. That deduction counts for more at Ontario's top marginal rates.

The mistake I see most often: people convert non-deductible mortgage debt into deductible investment debt, then use that borrowed money to buy the same top-heavy index they already hold. The structure works, but the concentration gets worse. Before your next readvance, ask what the borrowed money should fill. Options include global ex-North America exposure, small and mid caps, or sectors that make up little of the TSX. Choosing on that basis turns the strategy into a way to rebalance, not just a way to add leverage.

Not everyone should do this. Debt conversion needs a readvanceable mortgage, steady cash flow with room to spare and a long investment horizon. If your renewal is coming up, that's a good time to review how your mortgage is set up as well as what rate you'll pay. A structure that supports your investment plan often matters more than a small difference in rate.

A fair counterpoint: large index weights have not always led to losses. The biggest companies are often the most profitable, and active funds that try to avoid them can cost more in fees than they save. The aim isn't to drop index funds. It's to know what you own and to stop adding to it without realizing.

Item 2 is the one people skip. Fund math feels like investing, while listing your house beside your portfolio feels like a separate topic. For most Ontario homeowners, though, that column shows the biggest concentration risk.

*This is general information, not personalized financial, tax or investment advice. Leverage strategies carry risk, including losses on borrowed funds. Speak with a qualified advisor and tax professional before acting.*

---

**Sources**

1. TipRanks - SPY Holdings: All 505 Stocks in SPDR S&P 500 ETF (2026) - 2026-09-25\. [https://www.tipranks.com/etf/spy/holdings](https://www.tipranks.com/etf/spy/holdings?ref=ericavincellimortgage.contentflow.media)
2. Reuters via MarketScreener - Canadian financials' share of Toronto index hits 8-year high as bank valuations surge - 2026-08-06\. [https://www.marketscreener.com/news/canadian-financials-share-of-toronto-index-hits-8-year-high-as-bank-valuations-surge-ce7f50ddd981f227](https://www.marketscreener.com/news/canadian-financials-share-of-toronto-index-hits-8-year-high-as-bank-valuations-surge-ce7f50ddd981f227?ref=ericavincellimortgage.contentflow.media)
3. CREA - Canadian Real Estate Statistics - 2026-08-01\. [https://creastats.crea.ca/](https://creastats.crea.ca/?ref=ericavincellimortgage.contentflow.media)
4. Government of Canada - Complete List of US Products Subject to Counter-Tariffs - 2026-08-22\. [https://www.canada.ca/en/department-finance/programs/international-trade-finance-policy/canadas-response-us-tariffs/complete-list-us-products-subject-to-counter-tariffs.html](https://www.canada.ca/en/department-finance/programs/international-trade-finance-policy/canadas-response-us-tariffs/complete-list-us-products-subject-to-counter-tariffs.html?ref=ericavincellimortgage.contentflow.media)
5. Wealth Rebalancer - U.S. Dividend Withholding Tax Canada - 2026-06-20\. [https://wealthrebalancer.com/blog-us-dividend-withholding-tax-canada.html](https://wealthrebalancer.com/blog-us-dividend-withholding-tax-canada.html?ref=ericavincellimortgage.contentflow.media)