Get Erica's Mortgage Articles

Articles for Canadian homeowners and landlords on renewals, refinancing, investment properties, Cash Damming and the Smith Manoeuvre™.

Subscribe (Free) Erica Vincelli Mortgage cover image
  • Home
  • Locking In 5% Bond Yields or Rolling GICs: The Reinvestment Risk Question
Locking In 5% Bond Yields or Rolling GICs: The Reinvestment Risk Question
By Erica Vincelli profile image Erica Vincelli
3 min read

Locking In 5% Bond Yields or Rolling GICs: The Reinvestment Risk Question

A one-year GIC renews on a single day, at whatever rate the market happens to offer that morning. Most people who hold one feel safe. They're also making a quiet bet every twelve months that the next renewal will be as good as the last.

High-quality bonds have changed that bet. Investment-grade corporate issues in Canada are paying roughly 4.0% to 4.6% in 2026, and five-year Government of Canada bonds sit somewhere around 3.2% to 3.8%. If you've thought "I feel like I should lock something in before this disappears," that instinct deserves a proper test. Both choices carry risk. The bond can swing in price, and cash can renew lower. Which of those risks you can live with depends almost entirely on when you need the money back.

Measure the whole term, not the first year

Give both options the same job: $100,000 for five years. These numbers are illustrative.

Lock in: a five-year bond yielding 5% pays $5,000 a year, or $25,000 over the term if you hold it to maturity (simple interest, coupons not reinvested).

Roll cash: say short-term instruments pay 3.5% in year one. If short rates ease to 2.5% after year one and stay there, you earn $3,500 plus four years of $2,500, for $13,500. That's $11,500 less than the bond.

Turn it around. For rolling cash to match the bond, short rates have to average 5% across all five years. Ask yourself whether you'd confidently forecast that. Most professionals wouldn't, and that's the real meaning of reinvestment risk: the income you'll earn later is unknown today.

Price risk only costs you if you sell early

The bond's weakness is real. If inflation stays sticky and the Bank of Canada has to tighten again, the market value of existing bonds falls. As a rough guide, a five-year bond can lose somewhere around 4% of its price for each one-point rise in yields.

That loss stays on paper if you hold to maturity. You still collect every coupon and get your full principal back from a quality issuer. It becomes a real loss when you're forced to sell in the middle, which is why money earmarked for a down payment, a tax bill or a landlord's repair reserve can belong in cash even when cash pays less. Cash lets you pull the money without a bad price.

One more check: a 5% yield should come from quality. High-yield bonds paying similar numbers behave more like stocks in a recession, and that's a different decision entirely.

Tax and your mortgage set the real hurdle

Bond interest and GIC interest are both taxed at your full marginal rate, so tax doesn't separate these two options. Where you hold them does. Interest-bearing assets usually work harder inside an RRSP or TFSA, leaving room in non-registered accounts for investments that receive better tax treatment, such as eligible dividends and capital gains.

If you own a home, there's a third option sitting beside these two. Take an illustrative 5.2% bond in a non-registered account at a 40% marginal rate: you keep about 3.1% after tax. Prepaying an approximately 4.0% to 4.6% mortgage earns you a guaranteed return in that range with no tax owing. Run that comparison on your own numbers before buying any bond with spare cash. For people restructuring debt so the interest becomes deductible, the math shifts again, and it's worth modelling carefully with a professional, because no yield or deduction is guaranteed.

Let the date decide

Write down the date each pool of money is actually needed. If it's comfortably beyond a bond's maturity, locking in replaces an unknown string of renewals with a known income, and the price swings in between don't touch you. If the money might be needed sooner, cash's flexibility is worth the lower rate. Many investors split the difference with a ladder, so some money matures every year. Either way, match each dollar to its date first, and the choice between the two mostly makes itself.


Sources

  1. Vanguard Canada - Canadian Corporate Bond Index ETF - 2026-09-30. https://www.vanguard.ca/en/product/etf/fixed-income/1936/vanguard-canadian-corporate-bond-index-etf
  2. iShares (BlackRock) - iShares Core Canadian Corporate Bond Index ETF - 2026-10-19. https://www.blackrock.com/ca/investors/en/products/239485/ishares-canadian-corporate-bond-index-etf
  3. Bank of Canada - Selected bond yields - Bank of Canada - 2026-10-19. https://www.bankofcanada.ca/rates/interest-rates/canadian-bonds/
  4. Bank of Canada - short-term instruments pay 3.5% now - 2026-09-02. https://www.bankofcanada.ca/2026/09/fad-press-release-2026-09-02/