Own the loan, not the quote: why private credit beats bonds for yield-focused portfolios
Most investors who buy a bond ETF do not realize they are purchasing a price that moves rather than the payments that were promised. The distinction sounds technical. It is the difference between anxiety and sleep.
A public bond trades like a stock, even though it is not one. When interest rates rise, the bond's price drops immediately, and that drop shows up as a red number on every statement and dashboard. The borrower has not defaulted. The loan terms have not changed. The monthly interest still arrives. But the quote has moved, and the investor sees loss.
Private credit removes the quote. The investor owns the loan itself: a contract in which a mid-sized business borrows money at 8% to 12%, secured by real assets like equipment or commercial real estate, and pays back on schedule. The loan does not trade on an exchange. There is no ticker. The price on the statement does not fluctuate because there is no market setting a price every second. The contractual interest payment either arrives or does not, and a book value moves only when a default occurs or the loan is paid off.
The risk profile is materially different. In a public bond, the investor faces market risk: the bond's price can drop 15% in a matter of weeks if the Bank of Canada raises rates aggressively, even when the issuer is solvent. In private credit, the investor faces credit risk: the borrower might default, but if the borrower keeps paying, the yield stays exactly where it was promised. For a 60-year-old investor three years from retirement, that structural difference is meaningful.
The illiquidity premium exists because most people cannot handle it
Private credit typically pays approximately 425 to 500 basis points more than comparable public bonds, which on a public bond yielding 8% would place private debt yields at 12% to 13%. The spread compensates for illiquidity. Most private debt funds in Canada are structured as Offering Memorandum funds with lock-up periods between six months and two years, and redemptions are available only quarterly or annually. If an investor needs the cash in month four, they cannot get it.
The industry calls this the "illiquidity premium." A clearer term is the "watching someone else panic and being unable to join them" premium. When public markets correct and bond ETFs are down 12%, investors in private credit do not see the correction on their statement because the loans are still paying and the borrowers are still solvent. But because there is no market quote, there is no emotional trigger to sell.
This sounds like a flaw dressed up as a feature, and for some investors it is. Illiquidity is a real constraint. For yield-focused portfolios where the goal is income rather than optionality, the constraint is often the point. A retiree drawing 6% annually from a private debt fund does not need daily liquidity. They need the distributions to keep showing up, and they need to avoid the behavioural mistake of selling into a market correction because the number on the screen turned red.
Covenant control and security: private lenders sit first
Public bondholders are unsecured creditors in most cases, standing behind the bank and often behind other lenders. Private credit in Canada is typically structured as senior secured debt, meaning the lender has first claim on specific assets if the borrower defaults. In a construction loan backed by a multi-family development in Ottawa, the private lender's position is ahead of the mezzanine debt, the equity investors, and any trade creditors.
More importantly, private lenders negotiate maintenance covenants. If the borrower's debt-service coverage ratio drops below 1.25x, the lender can intervene, renegotiate terms, or demand early repayment before a full default occurs. A retail investor holding units in a corporate bond ETF has no such mechanism. The covenant is set at issuance, and if the company breaches it, the bondholder finds out when the price drops.
This is not a guarantee against loss. Private credit defaults happen, and when they do, recovery can take years. But the structure gives the lender tools that a passive bondholder does not have, and in a rising-rate environment where many businesses face refinancing pressure in 2026 and 2027, those tools matter.
Private credit requires accredited investor status in most cases, and the tax treatment is worse than capital gains. For an investor who wants yield, can afford to lock up capital, and would rather own the loan than watch the quote, the investment is grounded in real structural economics rather than speculation about market movements.
Most investors who buy a bond ETF do not realize they are purchasing a price that moves rather than the payments that were promised. The distinction sounds technical. It is the difference between anxiety and sleep.
A public bond trades like a stock, even though it is not one. When interest rates rise, the bond's price drops immediately, and that drop shows up as a red number on every statement and dashboard. The borrower has not defaulted. The loan terms have not changed. The monthly interest still arrives. But the quote has moved, and the investor sees loss.
Private credit removes the quote. The investor owns the loan itself: a contract in which a mid-sized business borrows money at 8% to 12%, secured by real assets like equipment or commercial real estate, and pays back on schedule. The loan does not trade on an exchange. There is no ticker. The price on the statement does not fluctuate because there is no market setting a price every second. The contractual interest payment either arrives or does not, and a book value moves only when a default occurs or the loan is paid off.
The risk profile is materially different. In a public bond, the investor faces market risk: the bond's price can drop 15% in a matter of weeks if the Bank of Canada raises rates aggressively, even when the issuer is solvent. In private credit, the investor faces credit risk: the borrower might default, but if the borrower keeps paying, the yield stays exactly where it was promised. For a 60-year-old investor three years from retirement, that structural difference is meaningful.
The illiquidity premium exists because most people cannot handle it
Private credit typically pays approximately 425 to 500 basis points more than comparable public bonds, which on a public bond yielding 8% would place private debt yields at 12% to 13%. The spread compensates for illiquidity. Most private debt funds in Canada are structured as Offering Memorandum funds with lock-up periods between six months and two years, and redemptions are available only quarterly or annually. If an investor needs the cash in month four, they cannot get it.
The industry calls this the "illiquidity premium." A clearer term is the "watching someone else panic and being unable to join them" premium. When public markets correct and bond ETFs are down 12%, investors in private credit do not see the correction on their statement because the loans are still paying and the borrowers are still solvent. But because there is no market quote, there is no emotional trigger to sell.
This sounds like a flaw dressed up as a feature, and for some investors it is. Illiquidity is a real constraint. For yield-focused portfolios where the goal is income rather than optionality, the constraint is often the point. A retiree drawing 6% annually from a private debt fund does not need daily liquidity. They need the distributions to keep showing up, and they need to avoid the behavioural mistake of selling into a market correction because the number on the screen turned red.
Covenant control and security: private lenders sit first
Public bondholders are unsecured creditors in most cases, standing behind the bank and often behind other lenders. Private credit in Canada is typically structured as senior secured debt, meaning the lender has first claim on specific assets if the borrower defaults. In a construction loan backed by a multi-family development in Ottawa, the private lender's position is ahead of the mezzanine debt, the equity investors, and any trade creditors.
More importantly, private lenders negotiate maintenance covenants. If the borrower's debt-service coverage ratio drops below 1.25x, the lender can intervene, renegotiate terms, or demand early repayment before a full default occurs. A retail investor holding units in a corporate bond ETF has no such mechanism. The covenant is set at issuance, and if the company breaches it, the bondholder finds out when the price drops.
This is not a guarantee against loss. Private credit defaults happen, and when they do, recovery can take years. But the structure gives the lender tools that a passive bondholder does not have, and in a rising-rate environment where many businesses face refinancing pressure in 2026 and 2027, those tools matter.
Private credit requires accredited investor status in most cases, and the tax treatment is worse than capital gains. For an investor who wants yield, can afford to lock up capital, and would rather own the loan than watch the quote, the investment is grounded in real structural economics rather than speculation about market movements.
Sources
Read Next
How the Federal 2026 Budget Could Reshape Canada’s Mortgage Market
Beyond the Rate Hike: Why Financial Strategy Matters
The Bank of Canada Raises Rates: What Does This Mean for Borrowers?
A Plan for Every Dollar of the $6,883 Child Benefit, Ages 6 to 17