Get Erica's Mortgage Articles

Articles for Canadian homeowners and landlords on renewals, refinancing, investment properties, Cash Damming and the Smith Manoeuvre™.

Subscribe (Free) Erica Vincelli Mortgage cover image
  • Home
  • Six Straight ETF Records: The Fee Compounding Math Pulling Money From Mutual Funds
Six Straight ETF Records: The Fee Compounding Math Pulling Money From Mutual Funds
By Erica Vincelli profile image Erica Vincelli
3 min read

Six Straight ETF Records: The Fee Compounding Math Pulling Money From Mutual Funds

Back in 2025, Canadian ETF assets set record inflows, with ETFs pulling in roughly $125.8 billion in net sales for the year, while mutual funds attracted $40.5 billion. That year, ETFs pulled in $125.8 billion in net sales against $40.5 billion for mutual funds. Mutual funds still hold far more money in total, around $2.1 trillion. The direction of new money, though, was clear.

The reason is arithmetic you can run on your own statement. An annual fee comes off your balance every year, so it compounds against you exactly the way returns compound for you. If you've ever looked at an MER and thought, "I feel like I should know what that's costing me," the math below will tell you. It also tells you when a mutual fund is still the right call.

A small percentage takes a large share

Here's an illustrative example, not a forecast. Take $100,000, a 6% gross annual return and 25 years, with nothing added.

  • Bundled mutual fund, 2.00% MER: net 4.0% a year grows to about $266,600.
  • Broad index ETF, 0.20% MER: net 5.8% a year grows to about $409,400.

The difference is roughly $142,800. A fee gap of 1.8 points, which sounds minor, ends up costing more than a third of what the cheaper portfolio is worth. This is how a mortgage works in reverse. With a mortgage, interest charged on the balance you still owe adds up over the years. With a fund, the fee charged on the balance you've grown does the same thing.

Put the advice back before you compare

That comparison is unfair to the mutual fund. A typical 2% MER includes payments to the advisor, so the ETF needs its advice cost added back. Many advisors now charge a separate fee and use ETFs or F-class funds so clients can see what they're paying.

Assume the same ETF plus a 1.00% advisory fee, so you pay 1.20% in total. At a net 4.8% for 25 years, $100,000 grows to about $322,900. That's still around $56,000 ahead of the bundled fund, with the same advice. The gain comes from paying for advice as a separate line, where you can see it and question it.

Count the friction before switching

Lower fees only help if the move itself doesn't cost more. Three things to check:

  1. Tax in non-registered accounts. Selling a mutual fund with gains triggers capital gains tax now. Inside an RRSP or TFSA there's no tax hit, which makes those accounts the easy place to start.
  2. Trading costs. ETFs trade on the TSX like stocks, so commissions and bid-ask spreads matter if you buy small amounts often. Many Canadian brokerages now offer fractional ETF purchases, which handles most automatic monthly contributions.
  3. Older redemption charges. Some older holdings may still carry exit fees. Check before you sell.

ETFs also tend to pay out fewer capital gains distributions in taxable accounts. That helps you after the switch, on top of the lower MER.

Low fees help most when you're borrowing to invest

The math matters most when the money is borrowed. With the Smith Manoeuvre™, you gradually convert mortgage debt into a tax-deductible investment loan. That only builds wealth if your investment returns, after costs, stay above what you pay to borrow. Broad market index ETFs often charge under 0.10%. On borrowed money, a 2% MER can wipe out most of that margin. Returns are never guaranteed, and a falling market still hurts a leveraged account. High fees cut into the return on a borrowed dollar every year, whether markets rise or fall.

The deciding condition

ETFs win on cost almost every time. What a bundled mutual fund can still offer is advice, folded into a price you never see as a separate line. So the decision comes down to one question. Can you name what you pay for advice each year in dollars, and is that advice worth that amount to you? If you can't answer, start by finding the number on your statement.


Sources

  1. Investment Executive - Record fund assets, record ETF inflows in 2025 - 2026-01-28. https://www.investmentexecutive.com/news/record-fund-assets-record-etf-inflows-in-2025/
  2. Wealth Professional - Canadian ETF assets top $896bn as bond funds drive July surge - 2026-08-25. https://www.wealthprofessional.ca/investments/etfs/canadian-etf-assets-top-896bn-as-bond-funds-drive-july-surge/393360