Get Erica's Mortgage Articles

Articles for Canadian homeowners and landlords on renewals, refinancing, investment properties, Cash Damming and the Smith Manoeuvre™.

Subscribe (Free) Erica Vincelli Mortgage cover image
  • Home
  • The Smarter Algorithms Get, the More Clients Value Being Understood
The Smarter Algorithms Get, the More Clients Value Being Understood
By Erica Vincelli profile image Erica Vincelli
2 min read

The Smarter Algorithms Get, the More Clients Value Being Understood

Both pressures land on the same desk. Clients will pay less and less for arithmetic, and they'll keep paying for someone who understands them well enough to keep the plan intact when they're scared. If you run a practice or a wealth team, that should shape where your hours, your hiring and your fee conversations go over the next few years.

Software owns the math now, so price the judgment

A planning tool can run a thousand scenarios before you finish your coffee. It can model a mortgage renewal, a rebalancing, a retirement drawdown. Clients know this, which is why "I pay you to build my allocation" is a weak answer when fees come up.

What the tool can't do is decide which of those thousand scenarios this family will actually stick with. Investors consistently raise accuracy and lack of personal context as concerns about AI advice. Personal context is the part they're asking you to supply. Regulators see it the same way: CIRO has kept the Know Your Client obligation with the registrant, and the OSC has been tightening its watch on AI-driven platforms and finfluencers giving advice without the human accountability behind it.

The value shows up in the bad month

I see this most clearly with debt strategies like the Smith Manoeuvre™, where a homeowner converts mortgage debt into investment borrowing that may be tax-deductible.

Here's an illustrative example. Say a client has $100,000 borrowed on the readvanceable portion of their mortgage and invested in a non-registered account. At an assumed 6% interest rate, that's $6,000 a year in interest. If the borrowing qualifies under CRA rules and the client sits at an assumed 43% marginal tax rate, the deduction is worth about $2,580 a year ($6,000 × 43%), so the after-tax cost is roughly $3,420. Those numbers depend on the actual rate, the client's bracket and how the funds are used. Returns aren't guaranteed, and the investments can fall.

Any decent calculator will produce that math. Now picture the market down sharply and the client calling to sell everything and pay off the line. The calculator has no reply. Someone who knows this client's timeline, their kids, the reason they started, can walk them through whether the plan still holds. A 2024 J.D. Power study found the biggest driver of investor loyalty in Canada was proactive, personalized guidance during market volatility. That's the moment clients remember, and it's the moment they pay for.

Lending rules add their own layer that a client rarely tracks. Under OSFI guidance the revolving portion of a home equity line is capped at 65% of home value, with combined mortgage and line borrowing limited to 80%. A household that has already used most of that room has less flexibility in a downturn, and the person advising them needs to have said so before the downturn arrives.

Move the saved hours into conversations

The advisors gaining ground are using software for the paperwork, the reporting and the scenario runs, then spending the recovered time with clients before stress hits. Many younger investors still want a human for major milestones like a mortgage renewal or an estate plan, which tells you where those hours belong.

Look at your own calendar for last month. Count the hours that went into work a tool could have done, and the hours spent learning what a client is afraid of. As the software keeps improving, the second number is the one your fees will rest on.


Sources

  1. RateHub - HELOC rates Canada — Best Home Equity Line of Credit rates - 2026-09-16. https://www.ratehub.ca/best-mortgage-rates/heloc